Sweet 16 has a critical mass

The Ron & Genie Calgaard Gym at Trinity University in San Antonio, Texas, won't be hosting Division III women's basketball this weekend. In fact, Texas hasn't hosted a sectional since 2008 in women's basketball, and never in men's basketball since the current playoff system came into play in 2000. 
Trinity (Texas) athletics photo
 

By Pat Coleman
Executive Editor
D3sports.com

As announced on Saturday night and Sunday morning, the men's sectionals will be hosted at Christopher Newport, Randolph-Macon, Mount Union and Swarthmore. The women's sectionals will be hosted at Babson, Smith, Tufts and Transylvania.

  • 2023 NCAA Tournament bracket: Men | Women
  • More NCAA Tournament headlines: Men | Women

Just one in the past 56 sectionals in Division III women's basketball has been hosted by a school currently in Region 10, and in men's basketball, just one sectional in the entire history of the current system -- 84 sectionals -- has been hosted by a school currently in Region 10.

This was a year in which the NCAA could have given the Region 10 women a bit of a makeup call. So many years, the decision has been made by seeding, except when it costs more money to maintain seeds. Then seeds are out the window.

This year, there is a women's sectional which includes Christopher Newport, Trinity (Texas), Tufts and Wartburg. None of these schools are within 500 miles of each other. It costs more or less the same no matter which of these four schools hosts. Christopher Newport cannot, because the men are hosting this weekend. 

But even so, when the money is not the object, Trinity and Region 10 still do not get the call. This is allegedly a call strictly on seeding, but if the NCAA really wanted to represent Region 10, it certainly could have justified giving the sectional to Trinity. Trinity was even ranked ahead of Tufts in the Top 16 when the committee released them in mid-February.

This is a miss, and only adds fuel to the fire from the American Southwest Conference, Northwest Conference, Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference and Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference when they ask Division III leadership why they get snubbed on a regular basis. 

Of course, over the years, hosting the sectional has hardly been a golden ticket to the Final Four. In fact, hosts succeed in doing so less than half of the time. Here's the breakdown:

Women's sectional hosts: 47% success rate

Since the format of the NCAA Tournament changed in the 2000 season, all four sectional hosts have advanced to the Final Four just twice in 22 seasons. On two occasions, none of the four sectional hosts have advanced. Because of COVID-19, the sectionals were not played in 2020 and the entire tournament was not played in 2021. Teams in bold advanced to the Final Four.

Teams are listed with their current region, in the 10-region alignment.

 
Year School Region School Region School Region School Region
2023 Tufts 1 Babson 2 Smith 2 Transylvania 8
2022 Amherst 1 Hope 7 Transylvania 8 UW-Whitewater 9
2020 Bowdoin 1 Tufts 1 Amherst 1 Hope 7
2019 Bowdoin 1 Scranton 5 Thomas More 7 St. Thomas 9
2018 Amherst 1 Scranton 5 Hope 7 Wartburg 9
2017 Amherst 1 Ohio Northern 7 Washington U. 8 St. Thomas 9
2016 Amherst 1 Scranton 5 Thomas More 7 St. Thomas 9
2015 Tufts  1 Montclair State 4 Thomas More  7 Calvin 7
2014 Tufts 1 FDU-Florham 4 DePauw 7 Whitman 10
2013 Amherst 1 Williams 1 DePauw 7 UW-Whitewater 9
2012 Amherst 1 Mary Washington 6 Mount Union 7 Chicago 8
2011 Amherst 1 Lebanon Valley 5 Thomas More 7 UW-Stevens Point 9
2010 Amherst 1 Kean 4 Illinois Wesleyan 8 Washington U. 8
2009 Amherst 1 Rochester 3 Thomas More 7 Illinois Wesleyan 8
2008 Kean 4 Messiah 5 UW-Whitewater 9 Howard Payne 10
2007 Emmanuel 1 NYU 4 Scranton 5 Luther 9
2006 Southern Maine 2 Scranton 5 DePauw 7 Pacific Lutheran 10
2005 Southern Maine 2 Scranton 5 Randolph-Macon 6 Calvin 7
2004 Bowdoin 1 Marymount 5 Thomas More 7 UW-Stevens Point 9
2003 King's 4 Rochester 3 UW-Eau Claire 9 Hardin-Simmons 10
2002 Springfield 2 Salisbury 5 Wilmington 7 UW-Stevens Point 9
2001 NYU 4 TCNJ 4 Baldwin-Wallace 7 St. Thomas 9
2000 St. Lawrence 3 Rowan 4 Washington U. 8 Hardin-Simmons 10

Men's sectional hosts: 45% success rate

Since 2000, all four sectional hosts have never advanced to the Final Four, although on four separate occasions, three teams have advanced. There has never been a year in which no sectional host moved on, but six times, just one sectional host has advanced. In 2013 and 2020, there were no sectionals because of the tournament format, and in 2021 there was no Division III NCAA Tournament. Teams in bold advanced to the Final Four.

Year School Region School Region School Region School Region
2023 Swarthmore 5 Christopher Newport 6 Randolph-Macon 6 Mount Union 7
2022 Randolph-Macon 6 Case Western Reserve 7 Marietta 7 Illinois Wesleyan 8
2020 None              
2019 Amherst 1 Hamilton 1 Augustana 8 UW-Oshkosh 9
2018 Ramapo 4 Swarthmore 5 Augustana 8 UW-Platteville 9
2017 Middlebury 1 Babson 2 Hope 7 Marietta 7
2016 Tufts 1 Oswego 3 Benedictine 8 St. Thomas 9
2015 Babson 2 Randolph-Macon 6 UW-Stevens Point 9 Augustana 8
2014 Amherst 1 Mary Washington 6 Illinois Wesleyan 8 UW-Stevens Point 9
2013 None              
2012 Middlebury 1 Franklin & Marshall 5 Wooster 7 UW-Whitewater 9
2011 Williams 1 Rochester 3 Wooster 7 Augustana 8
2010 Williams 1 St. Mary's (Md.) 5 Guilford 6 UW-Stevens Point 9
2009 Richard Stockton 4 Franklin & Marshall 5 John Carroll 7 Wheaton (Ill.) 8
2008 Plattsburgh State 3 Ursinus 5 Hope 7 Washington U. 8
2007 Amherst 1 St. John Fisher 3 Virginia Wesleyan 6 UW-Stevens Point 9
2006 Amherst 1 Virginia Wesleyan 6 Wittenberg 7 Lawrence 9
2005 Amherst 1 Ramapo 4 Albion 7 UW-Stevens Point 9
2004 Williams 1 Franklin & Marshall 5 Wooster 7 Puget Sound 10
2003 Williams 1 Randolph-Macon 6 Wooster 7 Buena Vista 8
2002 Brockport 3 Catholic 5 Otterbein 7 Carthage 8
2001 Clark 2 Christopher Newport 6 Ohio Northern 7 Chicago 8
2000 Cortland State 3 William Paterson 4 Calvin 7 Buena Vista 9