| School | Location | Conference |
| Anderson | Anderson, IN | HCAC |
| Augustana | Rock Island, IL | CCIW |
| Aurora | Aurora, IL | NATHC |
| Beloit | Beloit, WI | MWC |
| Benedictine | Lisle, IL | NATHC |
| Blackburn | Carlinville, IL | SLIAC |
| Bluffton | Bluffton, OH | HCAC |
| Carroll | Waukesha, WI | MWC |
| Carthage | Kenosha, WI | CCIW |
| Chicago | Chicago, IL | UAA |
| Concordia (Wis.) | Mequon, WI | NATHC |
| Concordia-Chicago | River Forest, IL | NATHC |
| Cornell | Mount Vernon, IA | MWC |
| Defiance | Defiance, OH | HCAC |
| Dominican | River Forest, IL | NATHC |
| Earlham | Richmond, IN | HCAC |
| Edgewood | Madison, WI | NATHC |
| Elmhurst | Elmhurst, IL | CCIW |
| Eureka | Eureka, IL | SLIAC |
| Fontbonne | St. Louis, MO | SLIAC |
| Franklin | Franklin, IN | HCAC |
| Greenville | Greenville, IL | SLIAC |
| Grinnell | Grinnell, IA | MWC |
| Hanover | Hanover, IN | HCAC |
| Illinois College | Jacksonville, IL | MWC |
| Illinois Wesleyan | Bloomington, IL | CCIW |
| Knox | Galesburg, IL | MWC |
| Lake Forest | Lake Forest, IL | MWC |
| Lakeland | Sheboygan, WI | NATHC |
| Lawrence | Appleton, WI | MWC |
| MacMurray | Jacksonville, IL | SLIAC |
| Manchester | North Manchester, IN | HCAC |
| Maranatha Baptist | Watertown, WI | NATHC |
| Marian | Fond du Lac, WI | NATHC |
| Millikin | Decatur, IL | CCIW |
| Milwaukee Engineering | Milwaukee, WI | NATHC |
| Monmouth | Monmouth, IL | MWC |
| Mount St. Joseph | Cincinnati, OH | HCAC |
| North Central (Ill.) | Naperville, IL | CCIW |
| North Park | Chicago, IL | CCIW |
| Principia | Elsah, IL | SLIAC |
| Ripon | Ripon, WI | MWC |
| Rockford | Rockford, IL | NATHC |
| Rose-Hulman | Terre Haute, IN | HCAC |
| St. Norbert | De Pere, WI | MWC |
| Transylvania | Lexington, KY | HCAC |
| Washington U. | St. Louis, MO | UAA |
| Webster | St. Louis, MO | SLIAC |
| Westminster (Mo.) | Fulton, MO | SLIAC |
| Wheaton (Ill.) | Wheaton, IL | CCIW |
| Wisconsin Lutheran | Milwaukee, WI | NATHC |