| Away | Home | Status | Links | |||
| Marian | 71 | No. 5 UW-Whitewater | 82 | Final | • | BX |
| Stevenson | 50 | No. 9 Catholic | 79 | Final | • | BX BX RC |
| No. 10 Illinois Wesleyan | 75 | No. 17 Washington U. | 83 | Final - OT | • | BX RC |
| No. 11 St. Mary's (Md.) | 89 | Lawrence | 80 | Final | BX BX RC | |
| Aquinas | 78 | No. 12 Calvin | 76 | Final | ||
| DePauw | 66 | No. 19 Rose-Hulman | 75 | Final | • | BX |
| No. 21 Ohio Wesleyan | 82 | Franklin | 66 | Final | • | BX |
| No. 23 Cortland State | 68 | SUNYIT | 75 | Final | • | BX |
| Montclair State | 66 | Rochester Tech | 63 | Final | ||
| Dubuque | 75 | Knox | 61 | Final | • | |
| Rutgers-Newark | 72 | Neumann | 77 | Final - OT | • | |
| Lancaster Bible | 70 | Ferrum | 90 | Final | ||
| St. Vincent | 72 | Penn St.-Fayette | 67 | Final | BX | |
| Mount Aloysius | 108 | Waynesburg | 116 | Final | • | |
| Washington College | 63 | Hood | 68 | Final | • | BX RC |
| Carnegie Mellon | 54 | St. John Fisher | 67 | Final | • | BX |
| Methodist | 87 | Covenant | 64 | Final | BX | |
| MacMurray | 67 | Dominican | 86 | Final | • | |
| Kenyon | 70 | Earlham | 76 | Final | • | BX |
| Eastern Maine CC | 64 | Maine-Presque Isle | 88 | Final | ||
| Albright | 60 | Kean | 68 | Final | • | BX RC |
| Salisbury | 66 | Elizabethtown | 72 | Final | • | BX RC |
| Mount St. Mary | 56 | Keystone | 69 | Final | • | BX RC |
| Guilford | 60 | Maryville (Tenn.) | 74 | Final | • | BX RC |
| Hiram | 103 | Case Western Reserve | 69 | Final | • | BX BX BX RC |
| Hanover | 65 | Mount St. Joseph | 61 | Final | • * | BX |
| Muskingum | 71 | Baldwin-Wallace | 68 | Final | • * | BX BX RC |
| Hardin-Simmons | 60 | Trinity (Texas) | 75 | Final | • | BX BX BX |
| North Central (Minn.) | 72 | Rockford | 100 | Final | • | BX |
| St. Thomas (Fla.) | 60 | Manchester | 73 | Final | BX | |
| Marietta | 79 | Ohio Northern | 77 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| Mount Union | 75 | Wilmington | 73 | Final | • * | BX |
| TCNJ | 67 | Drew | 66 | Final | • | BX RC |
| Heidelberg | 64 | Capital | 73 | Final | • * | |
| Mary Washington | 100 | Bayamon Central | 79 | Final | ||
| St. Norbert | 65 | Lake Forest | 47 | Final | • * | BX BX RC |
| Concordia-Moorhead | 95 | Presentation | 68 | Final | • | |
| Berry | 71 | Webster | 76 | Final | ||
| Eureka | 52 | Ill.-Springfield | 95 | Final | ||
| Central | 65 | Westminster (Mo.) | 75 | Final | • | BX RC |
| Huntingdon | 85 | Birmingham-Southern | 92 | Final | • | BX RC |
| Texas-Dallas | 87 | University of the Ozarks | 83 | Final | • * | RC |
| Wisconsin Lutheran | 73 | Silver Lake | 61 | Final | ||
| Augsburg | 81 | Bethany Lutheran | 72 | Final | • | |
| Cornell | 79 | Mount Mercy | 61 | Final | BX | |
| Cal Lutheran | 58 | Pacific Lutheran | 70 | Final | • | BX BX RC RC |
| Lakeland | 62 | Beloit | 75 | Final | • | |
| Grand View | 78 | Buena Vista | 66 | Final | ||
| Albion | 74 | Southwestern | 63 | Final | BX | |
| Crown | 49 | Luther | 74 | Final | • | |
| Nebraska Wesleyan | 70 | Simpson | 63 | Final | • | BX |
| Oglethorpe | 57 | Chapman | 60 | Final | BX BX BX | |
| Millikin | 29 | Adrian | 47 | Final | BX RC | |
| Millsaps | 56 | Rhodes | 58 | Final | • | |
| UC Santa Cruz | 62 | Caltech | 63 | Final | • | BX |
| John Carroll | 83 | Otterbein | 86 | Final | • * | |
| Olivet | 65 | Northwood (Fla.) | 81 | Final | BX BX BX RC | |
| Viterbo | 77 | UW-Stout | 96 | Final | ||
| Bethel | 92 | Martin Luther | 64 | Final | • | BX |
| Southern Methodist | 70 | McMurry | 67 | Final | ||
| George Fox | 57 | Northwest (Wash.) | 83 | Final | BX | |
| Occidental | 48 | Cal St. Fullerton | 76 | Final | BX BX | |
| Holy Names | 97 | Pacific | 89 | Final | BX RC | |
| Menlo | 67 | Pomona-Pitzer | 57 | Final | BX | |
| Redlands | 60 | Concordia-Irvine | 107 | Final | BX | |
| Knox | 56 | Edgewood | 83 | Final | • | BX RC |
