Anthony Beaird's lay-in with less than 10 minutes to play put the Scots up 68-53, but MacMurray netted treys on five of its next seven possessions to close the gap to 77-70. From there, the Scots went cold, hitting just one of eight shots, and the Highlanders pulled even at 80-80 at the 2:44 mark.
With 1:37 remaining, the Scots' Joe Terwelp missed two free throws, but Dibble came up with a key offensive rebound, and Hebeler drained a clutch three-pointer. Following another big offensive rebound by Monmouth, Dibble was fouled with 26 seconds to play, and he netted both tries for an 85-80 lead. Nick Hipsher's fifth three-pointer of the night cut the lead to two, but Dibble again went 2-for-2 from the line with 14 seconds left to seal the win.
For the 3-1 Scots, Hebeler led all scorers with 19 points and Terwelp had 16 points and 10 rebounds. Tucker Blaser added 11 boards.
Hipsher led five Highlanders in double figures with 18. MacMurray remains winless at 0-5.