Davis made 9-of-12 field goals and went 3-for-9 from the foul line for the Soaring Eagles (3-16, 3-6 Empire 8).
The Hawks (2-18, 0-9 Empire 8) and Elmira were tied, 50-50, at the end of regulation. The Soaring Eagles then outscored Hartwick, 16-6, in the overtime period.
Junior guard Tim Kindlon paced the Hawks with 20 points on 7-for-17 shooting. Freshman swingman Eddie McAdoo finished with 12 points and three assists, and freshman forward Josh Mackenzie contributed 11 points and four rebounds.
ELMIRA 66, HARTWICK 56 (OT) HARTWICK (2-18) Tim Kindlon 7-17 0-1 20, Greg Betancourt 1-5 0-0 3, Eddie McAdoo 4-8 0-0 12, Sterling Green 0-3 0-0 0, Mike Wawrzonek 2-11 0-0 6, Matt Simoneschi 2-5 0-0 4, Christopher Ward 0-1 0-0 0, Mike Leighton 0-0 0-0 0, Josh Mackenzie 4-11 2-2 11. Totals: 20-61 2-3 56. ELMIRA (3-16) Charles Henry 3-8 2-2 11, Matt O'Brien 3-5 0-0 9, Albert Davis 9-12 3-9 21, Micah Owens 2-6 2-6 6, Matt Keating 1-6 2-3 4, Nick Molak 0-1 0-0 0, James Brown 0-3 2-2 2, Serge Clement 4-8 4-10 13. Totals: 22-49 15-32 66. Hartwick 14-36-6--56 Elmira 27-23-16--66 3-Point Goals: Hartwick 14-33 (Tim Kindlon 6-13, Greg Betancourt 1-3, Eddie McAdoo 4-6, Mike Wawrzonek 2-5, Matt Simoneschi 0-1, Josh Mackenzie 1-5), Elmira 7-17 (Charles Henry 3-6, Matt O'Brien 3-5, Matt Keating 0-4, Serge Clement 1-2). Fouled Out: Hartwick (Tim Kindlon), Elmira (Micah Owens). Rebounds: Hartwick 31 (Mike Wawrzonek 7), Elmira 47 (Albert Davis 18). Assists: Hartwick 17 (Matt Simoneschi 8), Elmira 14 (Charles Henry, Matt O'Brien, Serge Clement 3). Total Fouls: Hartwick 22, Elmira 13.