Charbatji made 4 of 9 three-point field goals and had five rebounds and two steals for the Golden Bears (1-1), who trailed at halftime, 34-30.
The Hawks (0-2) made 12 of 29 field goals in the first half, but converted only 4 of 24 shots in the second half.
Junior guard Jon Godbout (St.Paul/Bristol, Conn.) had 17 points and six assists, and junior forward Jim Bayne (Bristol Central/Bristol, Conn.) finished with 13 points, seven rebounds and two blocked shots for Western New England.
Senior center Mike Wawrzonek (South Side/Rockville Centre, N.Y.) led Hartwick with 16 points on 5-for-9 shooting, including 4-for-8 from three-point range.
Junior guard Tim Kindlon (Bethlehem/Delmar, N.Y.) had 10 points, and freshman forward Eddie McAdoo (LaSalle Institute/Troy, N.Y.) contributed four points, nine rebounds and two steals for the Hawks.
Hartwick will travel to meet Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts for a non-conference game at 7 p.m. Tuesday.
Scotty Wood Tournament (Consolation Game) WESTERN NEW ENGLAND 62, HARTWICK 49 HARTWICK (0-2) Sterling Green 1-8 1-2 3, Mike Wawrzonek 5-9 2-2 16, Matt Simoneschi 0-1 2-2 2, Ramose Modesto 2-5 1-2 5, Tim Kindlon 4-9 0-0 10, Christopher Ward 0-1 0-0 0, Greg Betancourt 1-7 0-0 3, Eddie McAdoo 1-5 2-4 4, James Watkins 0-3 0-0 0, Josh MacKenzie 2-5 0-0 6. Totals 16-53 8-12 49. WESTERN NEW ENGLAND (1-1) Jim Bayne 6-16 1-4 13, Anthony Charbatji 7-16 0-0 18, Mike Cutler 0-4 2-3 2, Jeremy Sternstein 4-6 2-2 11, Jon Godbout 6-10 2-2 17, Asif Abdul-Wadud 0-1 0-0 0, Jason Cardinal 2-4 0-0 6, Riley Houk 0-0 0-0 0, Matt Gigliello 0-1 1-2 1. Totals 23-54 8-13 62. Hartwick 34-15--49 Western New England 30-32--62 3-Point Goals Hartwick 9-25 (Mike Wawrzonek 4-8, Tim Kindlon 2-6, Josh MacKenzie 2-3, Greg Betancourt 1-5, Matt Simoneschi 0-1, Ramose Modesto 0-1, Christopher Ward 0-1), Western New England 8-18 (Anthony Charbatji 4-9, Jon Godbout 3-4, Jeremy Sternstein 1-1, Jim Bayne 0-1, Mike Cutler 0-1, Asif Abdul-Wadud 0-1, Matt Gigliello 0-1). Fouled Out None. Rebounds Hartwick 38 (Eddie McAdoo 9), Western New England 35 (Jim Bayne, Mike Cutler, Jeremy Sternstein 7). Assists Hartwick 9 (Eddie McAdoo 3), Western New England 18 (Jon Godbout 6). Total Fouls Hartwick16, Western New England 13. A 102.